Hot Best Seller

The Smurfs #4: The Smurfette

Availability: Ready to download

Gargamel, si penyihir jahat mengirimkan Smurfin ke desa smurf! Gara-gara sering dijahili smurf-smurf yang lain, Smurfin yang merasa jelek, menjadi sedih dan terus menangis. Akhirnya, Papa Smurf merubah Smurfin menjadi smurf perempuan yang cantik. tentu saja semua smurf jatuh cinta padanya dan berlomba-lomba mendekatinya. namun akhirnya, kekacauan mulai terjadi di desa smur Gargamel, si penyihir jahat mengirimkan Smurfin ke desa smurf! Gara-gara sering dijahili smurf-smurf yang lain, Smurfin yang merasa jelek, menjadi sedih dan terus menangis. Akhirnya, Papa Smurf merubah Smurfin menjadi smurf perempuan yang cantik. tentu saja semua smurf jatuh cinta padanya dan berlomba-lomba mendekatinya. namun akhirnya, kekacauan mulai terjadi di desa smurf. DDC: 741.5


Compare

Gargamel, si penyihir jahat mengirimkan Smurfin ke desa smurf! Gara-gara sering dijahili smurf-smurf yang lain, Smurfin yang merasa jelek, menjadi sedih dan terus menangis. Akhirnya, Papa Smurf merubah Smurfin menjadi smurf perempuan yang cantik. tentu saja semua smurf jatuh cinta padanya dan berlomba-lomba mendekatinya. namun akhirnya, kekacauan mulai terjadi di desa smur Gargamel, si penyihir jahat mengirimkan Smurfin ke desa smurf! Gara-gara sering dijahili smurf-smurf yang lain, Smurfin yang merasa jelek, menjadi sedih dan terus menangis. Akhirnya, Papa Smurf merubah Smurfin menjadi smurf perempuan yang cantik. tentu saja semua smurf jatuh cinta padanya dan berlomba-lomba mendekatinya. namun akhirnya, kekacauan mulai terjadi di desa smurf. DDC: 741.5

30 review for The Smurfs #4: The Smurfette

  1. 5 out of 5

    Dana-Adriana B.

    Mi-am adus aminte de serialul animat de pe canalele germane, doamne ce mult imi placea. In schimb, citind povestea m-am strumfit de cap de atata strumfeala. Super amuzanta povestea cu Strumfita :))) m-am distrat cu copii citind-o.

  2. 4 out of 5

    Martin

    Funny how life is, isn't it? Around 1983-1988, I was reading French "bandes dessinées", and "Les Schtroumpfs" were early favourites. Then, over time, I migrated to other titles, like "Tintin" and "Astérix", then "Les Tuniques Bleues" and "Lucky Luke". A conservative estimate is I must have devoured at least a couple hundreds of such books. And then... I'd outgrown all that. Comic books, even as early as the mid-eighties, had started gradually replacing these French treasures, and then I forgot a Funny how life is, isn't it? Around 1983-1988, I was reading French "bandes dessinées", and "Les Schtroumpfs" were early favourites. Then, over time, I migrated to other titles, like "Tintin" and "Astérix", then "Les Tuniques Bleues" and "Lucky Luke". A conservative estimate is I must have devoured at least a couple hundreds of such books. And then... I'd outgrown all that. Comic books, even as early as the mid-eighties, had started gradually replacing these French treasures, and then I forgot about them. As a teenager, I was like "Oh yeah, I used to read that when I was younger..." I'd outgrown them and considered them "kids' books". I bet you know exactly what I'm talking about. But as you grow up you don't, you know, really remember. It's sort of locked away somewhere in your brain, that magic that you used to love as a young child. Fast forward to "now" (ie: 2013). I was in a bookstore looking for a book for my 8-year old son, and I came upon the Smurfs. I thought he might like to read about the Smurfs, as I had when I was his age. So I got him The Smurfs #1: The Purple Smurfs, an adaptation of the original Les Schtroumpfs noirs. As Borat would say: "Great success!" He absolutely loved it! The Smurfs are back, baby! As luck would have it, an omnibus collecting the first four "Schtroumpfs" books was published in August 2013, and I got him that too. But then, as we sat together and read these early Smurfs adventures, something happened and that little drawer in my brain, with the memories and whatnot of childhood, unlocked & opened itself, and I felt like I'd been missing out on something, and that I really must read these books again. This may seem corny to you, the jaded adult, but there's a part of you I'm sure that understands what I'm talking about. Nostalgia factors aside - and this is where the op-ed ends and the review begins - this is a great book. In the main feature, Gargamel wants to avenge himself of the Smurfs and so he devises the perfect way to go about it: he creates the Smurfette! The harmony and peaceful life the Smurfs were enjoying up to then gets disturbed when Smurfette arrives, and the results are hilarious. I probably enjoyed reading it more at 37 than I did when I was 8. Because when you're a kid, you're more focused on the pretty pictures and the general way the story is unfolding. But as an adult, I found that it was really well done, and that (wink-wink) there are things in there which will resonate with adults as well (if not more so). Those guys - Peyo and his collaborators - were smart! (This is especially true of "Astérix": the references and asides are funnier when you know the historical contexts and the stereotypes being alluded to - that usually happens after childhood). The second, shorter feature was originally published around Christmas time and the feel-good vibe is unmistakable. The Smurfs' winter food stash goes up in smoke, the threat of famine sets in and so they are forced to leave their village. They find refuge in an old castle and there, the castle's Lord tells them all his servants & his friends have deserted him since he lost his fortune. The Smurfs end up finding a treasure hidden in a hole. To thank them, the Lord offers them to split the treasure with them, but instead they only ask for enough food to last the winter. I do believe I've caught the Smurfs bug (again). I'll be re-reading these books - with my son or by myself - and I'm looking forward to re-discovering them.

  3. 5 out of 5

    Palimp

    Esta claro que cada obra hay que colocarla en su contexto, pero el mensaje machista es demasiado fuerte como para dejarlo pasar.

  4. 4 out of 5

    Alice Rachel

    This was hilarious! I think those who say Peyo is a misogynist just don't have a sense of humor. This is so satirical, how can anyone take it seriously? This was hilarious! I think those who say Peyo is a misogynist just don't have a sense of humor. This is so satirical, how can anyone take it seriously?

  5. 4 out of 5

    Buchstabenschloss

    Geschichte 1: Schlumpfine Gargamel hat die Idee eine Schlumpfine für die Schlümpfe zu erschaffen, die sie in den Wahnsinn treiben soll. Schlumpfine ist auch außergewöhnlich nervig, doch Papa Schlumpf kann ihre Eigenschaften nochmal etwas geradebiegen. Doch es wäre nicht die Schlümpfe, wenn sie es nicht Gargamel heimzahlen würden. Geschichte 2: Schlümpfe in Not Die Schlümpfe stehen kurz vor dem Winter und sammeln ihre Vorräte ein. Dann im Winter passiert es, ein Feuer, und alle Vorräte sind verbrann Geschichte 1: Schlumpfine Gargamel hat die Idee eine Schlumpfine für die Schlümpfe zu erschaffen, die sie in den Wahnsinn treiben soll. Schlumpfine ist auch außergewöhnlich nervig, doch Papa Schlumpf kann ihre Eigenschaften nochmal etwas geradebiegen. Doch es wäre nicht die Schlümpfe, wenn sie es nicht Gargamel heimzahlen würden. Geschichte 2: Schlümpfe in Not Die Schlümpfe stehen kurz vor dem Winter und sammeln ihre Vorräte ein. Dann im Winter passiert es, ein Feuer, und alle Vorräte sind verbrannt. Auf der Suche nach Nahrung, finden sie fernab ihres Dorfes eine vermeintlich verlassene Burg. Der Burgherr selbst schein arm zu sein, doch tief in der Burg versteckt finden die Schlümpfe einen Schatz und machen den armen Burgherren zu einem reichen Burgherrn. Seine Dankbarkeit zeigt er durch zahlreiche Nahrungsmittel für die Schlümpfe. Das Cover ist zauberhaft. Ich habe mich richtig auf Schlumpfine gefreut. Aber die Geschichte, in der Schlumpfine ihren großen Auftritt hat, ist einfach nur anstrengend. Es werden wirklich alle negativen Frauenklischees der armen Schlumpfine angedichtet. Das war mir persönlich leider zu viel und schoss damit auch weit über das Ziel hinaus. Es war super anstrengend zu lesen und sehen. Wenn das Thema nicht ganz so ausgereizt gewesen wäre, dann hätte ich es wohl weniger schlimm gefunden. Leider taucht Schlumpfine danach auch nicht mehr in der Geschichte auf. Da frage ich mich wo sie hin ist. Die zweite Geschichte hat mir da schon deutlich besser gefallen. Es zeigt, dass eine Hand die andere wäscht und man gemeinsam alles schaffen kann. Es gibt auch nette Menschen in der Welt der Schlümpfe. Und das lässt mich persönlich auch aufatmen. Ich hoffe, dass Schlumpfine in weiteren Comics dabei sein wird. Für mich gehört sie irgendwie dazu.

  6. 5 out of 5

    Tristan

    I have a 1976 hardback reprint in French from Dupuis. Originally published in book form in 1967 and serialised the year before in Spirou magazine, this episode is sadly very much of its time. The titular short story is just a collage of every negative stereotype of women, and is just one long sexist joke. The Schtroumfette is a curse sent by the Schtroumpfs’ archenemy. And the curse is made all the more potent as the Grand Schtroumpf, through misplaced kindness, makes her stereotypically irresist I have a 1976 hardback reprint in French from Dupuis. Originally published in book form in 1967 and serialised the year before in Spirou magazine, this episode is sadly very much of its time. The titular short story is just a collage of every negative stereotype of women, and is just one long sexist joke. The Schtroumfette is a curse sent by the Schtroumpfs’ archenemy. And the curse is made all the more potent as the Grand Schtroumpf, through misplaced kindness, makes her stereotypically irresistible by way of a cosmetic procedure. When I read this as a young boy, the sexism didn’t jump out at me, the mid-70s in France being very similar to the mid-60s and these sorts of things being ubiquitous, but as I didn’t get the “joke” this episode was simply tedious to me rather than funny. It was all about a really irritating character, and who wants to read that? I certainly didn’t and this was one cartoon that didn’t get read often. Revisiting decades later as a jaded middle aged but partially woke bloke, I find the “joke” offensive. I do try to read between the lines, as some of the fun is poked at the males, whose fallibility in the face of beauty is just as ridiculous as their irritation at “female” traits. But there’s very little irony there. There’s some criticism of society’s demonisation of females and its worship of artificial beauty standards, but it’s too much to ask little kids to get that subtext. All they see is a reinforcement of sexism. So this is a bad episode. The second short story in the collection is just boring. There’s no development in the story, no twists, nothing that could pass as social comment. Just bland pap. Oh well. Even classics have their bad patches.

  7. 4 out of 5

    Feirodenn

    Encore un album bien mené de Peyo sur le plan de la narration séquentielle, rythmée de gags, de jeux de mots et d'expressions idiomatiques dans lesquels le lecteur doit deviner le sens des mots schtroumpfs. Il faut cependant avouer que cet album a plutôt mal vieilli par rapport aux autres, la seule représentation féminine étant un stéréotype sexiste ambulant. Le personnage de la schtroumpfette ne se construit que par rapport à son degré de séduction et son rapport aux schroumpfs, elle va même ju Encore un album bien mené de Peyo sur le plan de la narration séquentielle, rythmée de gags, de jeux de mots et d'expressions idiomatiques dans lesquels le lecteur doit deviner le sens des mots schtroumpfs. Il faut cependant avouer que cet album a plutôt mal vieilli par rapport aux autres, la seule représentation féminine étant un stéréotype sexiste ambulant. Le personnage de la schtroumpfette ne se construit que par rapport à son degré de séduction et son rapport aux schroumpfs, elle va même jusqu'à modifier son apparence pour répondre aux attentes esthétiques des autres schroumpfs. Notons en plus qu'elle est envoyé par Gargamel pour semer la zizanie, ce qu'elle fait tout en provoquant une inondation volontairement dans le village. Bref, on retrouve une Ève schtroumpfette qui est la tentatrice à condamner et qui provoque la chute d'Adam/ des schtroumpfs. L'œuvre est bien évidemment à remettre dans son contexte des années 60, et cela n'enlève rien à la qualité de la narration graphique de Peyo.

  8. 4 out of 5

    Rangga Sukmawijaya

    Lagi-lagi Peyo berhasil membuat konflik "orang dewasa" menjadi ringan dan layak dikonsumsi oleh berbagai kalangan, termasuk anak-anak. Walaupun pada dasarnya cerita Smurfette, atau Smurfin dalam bahasa Indonesia, mirip dengan cerita tentang penciptaan Pandora dalam mitologi Yunani, namun Peyo cukup luwes mengadaptasinya ke dalam kehidupan para smurf. Smurfette diciptakan oleh Gargamel, penyihir musuh bebuyutan para smurf, sebagai alat untuk membalaskan dendamnya. Dan ia berhasil, harmoni kehidup Lagi-lagi Peyo berhasil membuat konflik "orang dewasa" menjadi ringan dan layak dikonsumsi oleh berbagai kalangan, termasuk anak-anak. Walaupun pada dasarnya cerita Smurfette, atau Smurfin dalam bahasa Indonesia, mirip dengan cerita tentang penciptaan Pandora dalam mitologi Yunani, namun Peyo cukup luwes mengadaptasinya ke dalam kehidupan para smurf. Smurfette diciptakan oleh Gargamel, penyihir musuh bebuyutan para smurf, sebagai alat untuk membalaskan dendamnya. Dan ia berhasil, harmoni kehidupan di desa smurf terguncang oleh kemunculan Smurfette. Bahkan bencana pun terjadi hingga banjir melanda desa kecil itu. Peyo juga pandai menonjolkan karakter tokoh perempuan dalam kehidupan para smurf yang semuanya laki-laki. Di cerita kedua kita akan melihat para smurf mengungsi karena kelaparan melanda desa mereka. Cerita kedua ini, meskipun cukup menarik, namun terasa dangkal sehingga seolah-olah cerita ini hanya dibuat untuk "menggenapi" buku komik ini.

  9. 4 out of 5

    Emmawiz

    2/5 - Ce livre a une valeur sentimentale toute particulière puisqu’il a été passé de génération en génération dans ma famille. C’est donc un crève-coeur pour moi de réouvrir ce livre et de découvrir que l’histoire de la schtroumpfette est tout bonnement sexiste ! C’est une vision très étriquée de la femme qui est donnée, réduite à des attributs futiles tels que sa médisance. Puis comme par magie parce qu’elle n’est pas suffisamment jolie on la relooke et boum tout le monde tombe amoureux ! Si j’ 2/5 - Ce livre a une valeur sentimentale toute particulière puisqu’il a été passé de génération en génération dans ma famille. C’est donc un crève-coeur pour moi de réouvrir ce livre et de découvrir que l’histoire de la schtroumpfette est tout bonnement sexiste ! C’est une vision très étriquée de la femme qui est donnée, réduite à des attributs futiles tels que sa médisance. Puis comme par magie parce qu’elle n’est pas suffisamment jolie on la relooke et boum tout le monde tombe amoureux ! Si j’ai une fille, je réfléchirai à 2 fois avant de lui transmettre cette BD et les clichés qui vont avec. Quoi qu’on puisse dire sur le potentiel humour de l’auteur, le lectorat est jeune et influençable et ne devrait jamais lire de telles inepties.

  10. 4 out of 5

    Gijs Grob

    De smurfin is Gargamels vijandige gift aan de smurfen en dit karakter is in haar debuutstrip dan ook behept met alle cliché irritante vrouwelijke eigenschappen die je kunt bedenken. Maar wie denkt dat dit een puur misogyn verhaal is, komt bedrogen uit, want de smurfen vergeven de smurfin ineens al haar fouten op het moment dat ze van lelijk in mooi veranderd... Dit zegt vooral iets over de mannelijke geest en het is dan ook vooral die die in dit album op de hak wordt genomen. Het tweede verhaal h De smurfin is Gargamels vijandige gift aan de smurfen en dit karakter is in haar debuutstrip dan ook behept met alle cliché irritante vrouwelijke eigenschappen die je kunt bedenken. Maar wie denkt dat dit een puur misogyn verhaal is, komt bedrogen uit, want de smurfen vergeven de smurfin ineens al haar fouten op het moment dat ze van lelijk in mooi veranderd... Dit zegt vooral iets over de mannelijke geest en het is dan ook vooral die die in dit album op de hak wordt genomen. Het tweede verhaal heeft niets van de satire van het eerste: het is een rechttoe rechtaan avonturenverhaal: het is winter en de voedselschuur van de smurfen vliegt in brand, dus moeten ze elders op zoek naar eten...

  11. 5 out of 5

    StrictlySequential

    1978 = 95pence Story: ***** It's full book length story that made me very surprised with how thought out it was compared to the usual Smurfare. Gargamel creates her with plain looks and she's annoying so when the Smurfs get sick of her and she's in tears Papa Smurf performs plastic surgery to create the Smurfette who's seen on the cover. The Smurfs' behavior towards her in contrast is what I found most interesting. This tome is also eventful action-wise. Art: **** Peyo is great in general but best 1978 = 95pence Story: ***** It's full book length story that made me very surprised with how thought out it was compared to the usual Smurfare. Gargamel creates her with plain looks and she's annoying so when the Smurfs get sick of her and she's in tears Papa Smurf performs plastic surgery to create the Smurfette who's seen on the cover. The Smurfs' behavior towards her in contrast is what I found most interesting. This tome is also eventful action-wise. Art: **** Peyo is great in general but best with the charming qualities of their village. The colors really stand out too.

  12. 4 out of 5

    Indy

    There are two stories in this book - The Smurfette and the Hungry Smurfs. The Smurfette was of great fun, as it was about how a female smurf could easily ruin the whole village of smurfs who are male. The Hungry Smurfs is like an ordinary smurf adventure story, in which their food storage was burn in winter, and they have to take on an adventure to look for food.

  13. 5 out of 5

    Devero

    La Puffetta resta una storia divertente con delle interessanti implicazioni, specialmente sul lato della coscienza e presa di coscienza, e sul cambiamento; mentre La Fame è fondamentalmente una favola. Ben strutturata, ma non è che ami particolarmente le favole. Comunque 3 stelle e mezza meritate.

  14. 4 out of 5

    Sarah Dunmire

    Silly and cute

  15. 5 out of 5

    Harumichi Mizuki

    Terus lanjutan ceritanya Smurfin mana?

  16. 5 out of 5

    Laure

    Cute af. That's my whole childhood. Cute af. That's my whole childhood.

  17. 5 out of 5

    April

    ♫ yet another children's book that I shouldn't like as much as I do ♫ ♫ yet another children's book that I shouldn't like as much as I do ♫

  18. 5 out of 5

    Gigi Kam

    This book was quite ok, but as I like to read story books more, I seldom read comic books, this book was good. I like it!

  19. 5 out of 5

    Fabio

    La storia della Puffetta fece guadagnare a Peyo accuse di sessismo e misoginia da parte del mondo femminista che si aggiunsero, o si sarebbero aggiunte, a quelle di antisemitismo, razzismo e comunismo. Uhm, forse ne ho dimenticate altre. Beh, un bel pacchetto per un fumetto considerato per bambini! Una cosa però forse va chiarita: la ricetta che usa Gargamella per creare la Puffetta e il risultato che ne consegue sono volutamente pieni di stereotipi per suscitare ilarità. Ovviamente, alcuni ride La storia della Puffetta fece guadagnare a Peyo accuse di sessismo e misoginia da parte del mondo femminista che si aggiunsero, o si sarebbero aggiunte, a quelle di antisemitismo, razzismo e comunismo. Uhm, forse ne ho dimenticate altre. Beh, un bel pacchetto per un fumetto considerato per bambini! Una cosa però forse va chiarita: la ricetta che usa Gargamella per creare la Puffetta e il risultato che ne consegue sono volutamente pieni di stereotipi per suscitare ilarità. Ovviamente, alcuni rideranno e altri no. Personalmente però ho visto nel fumetto una critica più generale ai comportamenti umani: non solo quindi allo stereotipo di donna superficiale, lunatica e capricciosa ma anche all'atteggiamento maschile di completa reverenza e assuefazione verso il mondo femminile. I Puffi infatti cadono ai piedi della Puffetta (la seconda però, quella bionda e bella, non alla prima bruttina che viene presa un po' in antipatia, eppure il carattere non è molto diverso) comportandosi da schiavetti ed esaudendo ogni suo desiderio, spegnendo di fatto la loro volontà e la loro personalità. Ogni Puffo ha generalmente un proprio carattere e delle proprie peculiarità che qui vengono messe un po' in disparte per piacere alla Puffetta. È quindi rappresentato un certo servilismo maschile che non sembra aver destato nessuna indignazione, al contrario della Puffetta. Si tratta di rappresentazioni volutamente stereotipate e innocenti che vogliono portare ad un sorriso. Secondo me, quindi, non c'è motivo di offendersi per gli stereotipi della Puffetta e bisognerebbe forse provare a scavare oltre e cercare di capire cosa volesse effettivamente dire l'autore, con la massima umiltà e con la consapevolezza di non poterlo sapere.

  20. 4 out of 5

    Helmut

    Eine Fundgrube für den Schtroumpfologen "La Schtroumpfette" Der Schlumpf an sich kam mir bisher eigentlich immer recht asexuell vor. Mit diesem Band ändert sich das, denn ein neues Element, das die Welt der Schlümpfe stark verändert, tritt ins Dorf - die Schlumpfine. Ein bisschen gemein, wie die ursprüngliche, einfache Schtroumpfette mehr als Störfaktor von den Schlümpfen wahrgenommen wird, bis sie durch ein "Endlich Schön"-Programm des Großen Schlumpfs läuft und als aufgedonnerte, großwimprige, w Eine Fundgrube für den Schtroumpfologen "La Schtroumpfette" Der Schlumpf an sich kam mir bisher eigentlich immer recht asexuell vor. Mit diesem Band ändert sich das, denn ein neues Element, das die Welt der Schlümpfe stark verändert, tritt ins Dorf - die Schlumpfine. Ein bisschen gemein, wie die ursprüngliche, einfache Schtroumpfette mehr als Störfaktor von den Schlümpfen wahrgenommen wird, bis sie durch ein "Endlich Schön"-Programm des Großen Schlumpfs läuft und als aufgedonnerte, großwimprige, wasserstoffblonde Sexbombe dann plötzlich von allen angehimmelt wird... "Le Faim des Schtroumpfs" Die Lieblingsspeise der Schlümpfe ist Salsepareille, auf deutsch Raue Stechwinde. Natürlich essen sie auch Äpfel, und Haselnüsse, und Maronen, und Pilze - aber nichts geht über die Stechwinde. Im Winter schneit es nun ziemlich heftig im Dorf der Schlümpfe, und Stechwinde wächst laut Wikipedia hauptsächlich im Mittelmeerraum, Asien und Afrika. Für einen Schtroumpfologen sind das nun erste Hinweise, wo man das Dorf der Schlümpfe zu suchen hat: Ein Gebiet im Mittelmeerraum, in dem es im Winter stark schneit... ein weiterer Hinweis: zum ersten Mal verlassen die Schlümpfe ihr Dorf, und wir sehen, wie abgelegen es ist. Kein Wunder, dass der Schlumpf bisher noch so unerforscht ist. Mir gefallen diese leichten, lockeren Geschichten sehr, und Peyos Zeichnungen sind wirklich äußerst liebenswert.

  21. 5 out of 5

    Sophie Henderson

    I decided to read this book as it fits into the graphic novel bingo board. It wasn't very interesting because it was quiet predictable with a simple story line to it. My favorite quote form this book is ' wheres the smurfette ' because they always seem like they are lost without her. Something I learnt from this book is; don't always do what other people tell you to do even when you know its not right. A character in this book that was interesting to me was Jokey Smurf as he is aways making prank I decided to read this book as it fits into the graphic novel bingo board. It wasn't very interesting because it was quiet predictable with a simple story line to it. My favorite quote form this book is ' wheres the smurfette ' because they always seem like they are lost without her. Something I learnt from this book is; don't always do what other people tell you to do even when you know its not right. A character in this book that was interesting to me was Jokey Smurf as he is aways making pranks on people and having a laugh. I would recommend this book to someone who likes reading with pictures.

  22. 4 out of 5

    Kerlip Bintang

    Komik ini mah gak usah di review kali ya. Smurf aja sendiri. Cuma saya rasa penulisnya selalu menyelipkan satu kata "smurf" yang memang dibiarkan tak ada "artinya" untuk membuat pembaca lebih penasaran. Brilliant lah. Karena waktu kecil dilarang membaca oleh ortu (menurut mereka membaca adalah sebuah kemalasan), so komik2 kayak gini baru aku baca sekarang2. Huaaawaaaa.. ketinggalan peradaban deh! Mulai sekarang mau koleksi buku smurf nih, Nina juga mau, Asterix juga. Toh ortu juga gak bisa protes Komik ini mah gak usah di review kali ya. Smurf aja sendiri. Cuma saya rasa penulisnya selalu menyelipkan satu kata "smurf" yang memang dibiarkan tak ada "artinya" untuk membuat pembaca lebih penasaran. Brilliant lah. Karena waktu kecil dilarang membaca oleh ortu (menurut mereka membaca adalah sebuah kemalasan), so komik2 kayak gini baru aku baca sekarang2. Huaaawaaaa.. ketinggalan peradaban deh! Mulai sekarang mau koleksi buku smurf nih, Nina juga mau, Asterix juga. Toh ortu juga gak bisa protes sekarang, kan dah pake duid sendiri belinya.

  23. 5 out of 5

    Nick

    While historic, with its introduction of Smurfette, this story is odd, with it's "girls are icky but beautiful" attitude. The creation of Smurfette, from a list of ingredients representing the bad aspects of human nature, seems oddly like an attack. Of course, all the male Smurfs fall over themselves to do whatever she wants, even when it's a bad idea, which is cute and funny...but also smacks of Eve and the apple, they way it's presented. Smurfette is never evil, but she certainly is capable of While historic, with its introduction of Smurfette, this story is odd, with it's "girls are icky but beautiful" attitude. The creation of Smurfette, from a list of ingredients representing the bad aspects of human nature, seems oddly like an attack. Of course, all the male Smurfs fall over themselves to do whatever she wants, even when it's a bad idea, which is cute and funny...but also smacks of Eve and the apple, they way it's presented. Smurfette is never evil, but she certainly is capable of doing great amounts of harm, as presented in this story.

  24. 4 out of 5

    Desi Puspitasari

    Smurf jadi-jadian ciptaan Gargamel dikirim ke desa Smurf untuk membikin kacau. Tapi Papa Smurf berhasil mengubahnya menjadi seekor smurf yang cantik. Tapi tetep aja ... kacau! Smurf Gerutu di sini lucu! "Aku tidak suka Smurfin!" menggerutu pergi. tapi setelah nggak ada seekor Smurf yang lain, dia diam-diam nulis di tembok rumah: 'Love Smurfin' Smurf jadi-jadian ciptaan Gargamel dikirim ke desa Smurf untuk membikin kacau. Tapi Papa Smurf berhasil mengubahnya menjadi seekor smurf yang cantik. Tapi tetep aja ... kacau! Smurf Gerutu di sini lucu! "Aku tidak suka Smurfin!" menggerutu pergi. tapi setelah nggak ada seekor Smurf yang lain, dia diam-diam nulis di tembok rumah: 'Love Smurfin'

  25. 4 out of 5

    Kira

    My boys ages 4-7 love all things Smurf. Graphic novels are the perfect read for them.

  26. 4 out of 5

    Duane

    Another great Smurf graphic novel! The artwork is top notch and the storyline is very interesting. A side note is how it's interesting how the storyline is so different from the tv cartoon version. Another great Smurf graphic novel! The artwork is top notch and the storyline is very interesting. A side note is how it's interesting how the storyline is so different from the tv cartoon version.

  27. 4 out of 5

    Bunga Mawar

    coba deh... siapa yang tahu itu wujud dari salah satu bahan ramuan Gargamel untuk menciptakan Smurfin ini: "...sehelai kegenitan..." coba deh... siapa yang tahu itu wujud dari salah satu bahan ramuan Gargamel untuk menciptakan Smurfin ini: "...sehelai kegenitan..."

  28. 5 out of 5

    Chris

    Worth reading.

  29. 4 out of 5

    Valerie

    it's hilarious I like the story where the smurfette were made from the begin and the end. her personality is changing so it won't be boring for me..... it's hilarious I like the story where the smurfette were made from the begin and the end. her personality is changing so it won't be boring for me.....

  30. 5 out of 5

    robynluckystars

    Almost like an origin story for the smurfette :D

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Loading...
We use cookies to give you the best online experience. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.